A PNP client posted this question in our forums yesterday. Honestly, it can be a tough question to answer. Not so much because of all the conflicting information out there, BUT most people who start out with a little weight to lose yet still have a lot of body fat DON'T love the answer.
See, just like me and you, these girls love the scale feedback. They want low numbers and dropping body fat doesn't always yield the number you want to SEE on the scale. Lately I have sent the scale to Chris' office to live for a month. I'm simply NOT WEIGHING because I want to make some physique changes. To do that while still swelling from surgery means the scale is going to reflect a lot of lies.
My example is this: twice this last week I woke up and felt GOOD. I mean, rolled up out of the bed and thought I am tight and looking nice. Got on the scale...up 2lbs, 3lbs, 4lbs!!!! Are you kidding me? 4-freaking-pounds in a week? Ugh. Then I mope around the rest of the day feeling like a failure and asking Chris with tears in my eyes, "do I look like I have gained 4lbs? I'm trying so hard!"
So, here is a summary of her question and then my response. YOU CAN THANK THE PNP girls for this blog. This information is what they PAY FOR and they said I should share it with all of you because a lot of blog readers would love to hear it. They are the sweetest girls and, like me, they want everyone to feel as good as they do and have the chance to change their life. Thanks PNP GIRLS!
I am 5' 5" and 136 pounds. My goal is to be 130 by the time the year ends which will be very doable. My ultimate goal is only around 125, along with incorporating healthy habits (I tend to get into an all or nothing mentality, so I'd prefer to lose slow and realistically than hardcore diet for a week then give up).
My current body fat percentage is 31% according to my scale. I know those aren't always the most accurate but I'd guess that is fairly accurate based upon the size of clothes I wear (usually 8) and the fact that I haven't done much weight training in the past year or two. I'd like to set a goal for body fat percentage to reach by the end of the year but am not sure what is reasonable.
With fairly clean eating, sticking within calorie range and working out 4-5 times a week, what is realistic for me to expect by the end of the year?
To lose body fat percentage more than just pounds or muscle I know weight training is key. Would you also recommend more steady state cardio versus high intensity to burn fat?
My advice is to work on losing sizes and not worry about the scale at all. You might very well never get below 130lbs and yet wear a size 4 or 6 without trouble.
Muscle is tight and compact yet it weighs the same as fat.
When you start weight training you are likely to build some muscle fairly fast because you haven't been doing anything for so long. The fat will hold on for dear life for about three to four weeks.
During this time, the scale goes up a few pounds and you feel things are tight. That's because you have added muscle and water BEFORE you have dropped that fat the body wants to hold onto.
Suddenly at about three to four weeks you have a FAT DUMP and drop the 3-4lbs you gained. This puts you back to your original scale number YET the pants are looser.
Why? Think of muscle as a brick of gold and fat as a bag of feathers. 4lbs of gold and 4lbs of feathers WEIGHT EXACTLY THE SAME. Pile them on them bed. The gold is small and the feathers take up your entire side of the room.
If I were to strap 4lbs of gold (muscle) to your body, it's tight and compact. If I strap 4lbs of feathers (fat) to you, there is lots of billowy volume hanging all over you. Those 4lbs of feathers are tough to cram in some jeans. 4lbs of gold aren't; it would be the prettiest Spanxx of your life.
So, for the first month of really working on losing body fat you are going to add 4lbs of gold and hold onto all the fat you currently have without seeing payback on the scale. Then when you dump 4lbs of feathers you lose a lot inches, you still have your gold holding you tight, and clothes look and feel better. Weightloss is nothing at first even if you LOOK better.
Not everyone goes through this but people with little to lose on the scale but a lot of fat to drop (anything over 22%) do go through this typically. The more weight you have to lose the more likely you are going to lose weight and add some muscle. I just don't want anyone shocked and scared out of strength training that first critical month.
My advice is to work a plan and don't weigh for a month. Really don't weigh for a month. Then see at the end of the month what the weight is and if you lost a 1-2% of body fat. It might be more but it may only be that month one. By the end of 12-16 weeks of hard work you will be AMAZED at the new shape.
Training Plan:
Cardio is cardio. I don't think any type is much better than the other outside of doing some cardio 3-6 times a week and a minimum of 20 min. hard or 60 min of intervals or steady state.
One day you may feel like a nice, long session. Go for it! The next time you only have 30 min. so you better work it like a tiger is on your tail. The shorter the more you need to feel like puking. The longer the more you need to be breathing very hard but able to hold out for the amount of time you have.
Use the Work Your Butt Off book. It has over 55 cardio routines for a variety of machines, body parts, and even track workouts. The workouts range from 20 min. to 60 min. and you WILL NOT GET BORED. The best part is most of the routines challenge your muscles, too, so you get some added strength training for the week. That burns more calories.
Find a Strength Training program on the site you like and WILL DO at least three days a week. We have over 30 now so I know you can find a goodie. Three days is where someone your size needs to train to drop body fat.
I have several non-subscribers can order:
REMEMBER: Strength always before cardio. If you have to miss workouts it is better to drop cardio first, strength gets done, and food is clean and filled with things that make you happy.
For building a food plan...look at my abs menu in the Phit Eating Forum. Those menus are right in your calorie range and will get you results for your body fat drop. If you don't like something just sub it out for something similar you do like.
Don't get caught up in the black and white. B and W isn't what makes it happen for you. You have to learn to do things to be consistent with your life. It's when you are B and W that you fall completely off and get nowhere. You'll have days where you will want to eat something "not clean" but not bad either. Like some people get freaked out if they want to eat lowfat waffles. OK...have the dang waffles. Don't avoid waffles for three days and then end up at the Donut Hut covered in powder sugar when a couple of lowfat waffles for three days with yogurt would've done the trick. :)
Thanks for asking a question everyone can benefit from! If any of my readers have questions please feel free to post a COMMENT and I will answer for you.